| Year | Pastor (or Vicar) |
| 1907 | Prof. E.L.Arndt |
| 1907-1911 | Rev. W. Hitzemann |
| 1911-1914 | Rev. P. Walther |
| 1915-1917 | Rev. L. Rosin |
| 1917 | Rev. A.G. Fehner |
| 1918-1920 | Rev. G. Garbarkewitz |
| 1921-1923 | Rev. J. Woelfle |
| 1924-1925 | Rev.A.Erthal asst. W. Eissfeldt (student) |
| 1926-1929 | Rev. E.F. Schroeder |
| 1930-1933 | Rev. O.F. Hinrichs |
| 1934-1938 | Rev. G.O. Juettner |
| 1939-1942 | Rev. A. Vehling |
| 1942-1945 | Rev. E. Roth |
| 1945-1947 | Rev. J. Kempff |
| 1948-1955 Vac.Past. | Rev. D. Bakalyar assist Vicar A. Marcis 52-53 Vicar E. Behling 53-54 Vicar L. Arndt 54-55 |
| 1955-1956 | Rev. R. Otto summer Rev B. Mueller ast.G. Mueller |
| 1956-1960 | Rev. F. Reimer |
| 1961-1963 | Rev. D. B. Krueger |
| 1964-1967 | Rev. W. L. Maunula |
| 1968 1988 | Rev. D. Brokopp *see below |
| 1989-1998 | Rev. R. Kobernick Assnt. Vicar B Schindel 92-95 |
| 1994-2012 | Outreach: Ralph Arndt |
| 1994-1996 | Native Outreach: Ted Renauld |
| 1998-2000 Vac.Past. | Rev. K. Sauer |
| 2000-2005 | Rev. N. Smith |
| 2006 Jan-Jul Vac.Past. | Rev. N. Otke |
| 2014-2016 | Rev. Justin Miller |
| 2016-2017 | Vicar Kai Buck |
| 2017-2018 | Vicar Matthew Fenn |
| 2006 – 2019 | Rev. James Wood |
| 2019 – Present | Rev. Alexander Timm |
